Hales & Company

PUBLISHED ARTICLES

Home
Services
Research
Hales Report
M&A Sourcebook
Published Articles
Statistical Snapshots
M&A Basics
Industry Links
Transactions
Strategic Alliances
Value of an Advisor
Professionals
About Us
Contact

Ten Steps to Becoming a Great Boss: Being a great boss is not about you; it's about your employees. Reinventing yourself as a leader is the first step in building a better team.

Leader's Edge, January 2008

Fast Focus

  • Everyone deserves a great boss. You can give your agency that gift by following some common sense ideas.
  • Hire the best, pay attention, make expectations clear, get out of the way, and reward success.

Allow me to introduce you to your new hire: This is the person who is going to make you look great. He will be a model worker and be emulated by the rest of your employees. He will be a great listener and always share credit for a team effort. He will demand an excellent output from himself and from those under him.

Do you want this person to be the next one on your agency's team? Well then, take a look in the mirror.

Anyone who is a boss today should try to transform him or herself into a great boss. If you can do this, you will be bringing to your staff the most important person in the company—reinventing a leader who is even more vital to everyone's success. That could be you. It's not a difficult position to attain, but like everything worthwhile in life, it takes your attention and your positive energy. Oh, and reading a slim little book. Sounds like a good way to start the year, right?

How to Become a Great Boss

Whether you're the CEO, sales manager, commercial lines manager or leader of the agency support staff, you probably have room to grow. Very likely, you can become a better boss. I know that's the case with me. As a boss, I realize the many ways I fall short of being a great leader like Jack Welch, Warren Buffett or Bill Gates. At the beginning of each year, these thoughts of growth seem to surface. As we enter the year, let's make a resolution to ourselves to become better bosses.

How? I regularly revisit that question by re-reading a slight but powerful book. It's called How to Become a Great Boss: The Rules for Getting and Keeping the Best Employees (Hyperion, 2002), by one of my favorite business authors, Jeffrey J. Fox. I've had this book since it came out and have read it many times over the past five years to help me reflect on myself and to make personal promises on becoming a better boss.

I highly suggest you get this book yourself, but I'm willing to give you the CliffsNotes version and to relate some of my observations from consulting with many brokers that relate to the topic.

The book opens with the question "Did you ever have a great boss?" and then notes that "everyone should have one, but not enough people do." That should be a mantra in our industry, where we see a perennial lack of new talent coupled with an aging workforce. Can you afford, in this environment, to give up your best employees? Being a great boss is not about you—it's about them. How you recruit, motivate and train employees is by being a boss whom people admire, emulate and seek out.

So here are my quick takes on the book's many short, easily digestible chapters.

Top 10 Steps

In an early chapter, Fox outlines 10 steps to becoming a great boss. When I read these simple rules, I wonder how many of them I attain. How about you?

  1. Hire only top-notch, excellent people.
  2. Put the right people in the right job. Weed out the wrong people.
  3. Tell your people what needs to be done.
  4. Tell your people why it is needed.
  5. Leave the job up to the people you've chosen to do it.
  6. Train your people.
  7. Listen to your people.
  8. Remove frustration and barriers that fetter your people.
  9. Inspect progress.
  10. Say "thank you" publicly and privately.

These 10 items are really the heart of the book. Read that list again and think about how truly simple and easy each one should be. Want a great salesperson? Hire a great one, or someone who could become great. Want to empower people to make your customers happy? Train them, knock the barriers out of their way, and then leave them alone to do it. Have a great month? Thank your staff in a meeting, with a party and in a personal note in the company newsletter.

But how many times do we let day-to-day pressures get in the way of making these happen? You're personally too busy, so you don't take enough time for listening, observing and motivating your staff. Sales are lagging, so you take on more client contact yourself instead of putting your energy into supporting the efforts of your staff.

Set the Example

People aren't very complicated. They will do as you do. If you roll in late or take long lunches, what do you think your people will do? Great bosses won't let that happen. They will lead by example, and the effort will show throughout their lives, not just at work. Whether it's work ethic, agency culture or a sales and service philosophy, your agency's employees will follow your lead. Your actions dictate theirs.

It's All About the Client

Fox turns some concepts on their head. For instance, who pays your employees and provides them with health insurance? If you said "I do," you'd be dead wrong. Your clients do. Everyone works for the clients. Therefore, every job should be designed to get or keep clients. And each employee should have this perspective. A great boss will impart that perspective and build the agency culture around it.

Groom 'em or Broom 'em

Great agencies and great bosses are constantly training, teaching, improving and growing their employees. If they cannot be groomed to constantly improve, Fox says you must "broom them." If you don't keep your house clean, you'll be tolerating mediocrity, which he calls management malpractice.

Hire Slow, Fire Fast

"The cost of a mis-hire is huge," says Fox. At certain levels, it can be destructive to the agency. That's why you must take your time, clearly considering candidates when you need to fill a vacancy. Then, if you do make a hiring mistake, fix it fast by firing fast. The cost of prolonging a bad employee's stint at the company rises greatly over time. Don't let it drag you down. A side benefit to firing fast is creating a culture that lets employees know you won't be tolerating mediocrity.

Create an 'A' Team

Fox uses the equation "A + A = A." Add ability and attitude to get your A player. Simply put as a sports analogy, a team of A players will always beat a team of C players. Hire only A players and you'll beat your competition. If you need to hire B players, make certain you know you can groom them up the alphabet.

Live Your Principles

Here's where you get your employees behind you and emulating you. Underlying all your actions must be a set of principles from which you don't deviate. You teach them to employees, either outright or by example. This will be the foundation of your agency's culture.

Delegate Down

This is easy to say but not as easy to do. Delegate work as far down as possible. Not delegating down is "dumbing down," says Fox. Here's the rub, though: Delegating without providing clear direction or proper training is not delegating, but rather relegating. Relegating employees to murky jobs sets the stage for errors and poor performance. To effectively delegate, you must trust your judgment and experience. Then let your people make the tough decisions and learn from their mistakes. In practice, you must avoid letting employees "delegate up" by seeking decisions from you on things they should be handling.

You Get What You Inspect, Not What You Expect

Delegating doesn't stop when you set expectations for what you want done. In fact, that's just the beginning. Great bosses know that inspection is critical to achieving your agency's goals. This is a learned skill. Inspections shouldn't be intrusive, interruptive or done impatiently. Don't leave this valuable task up to e-mails or voice mails. To effectively inspect, you must meet with and talk to your employees about their work. You want to avoid the potential gap between setting great expectations and getting great results.

Pay Attention and Listen

A common error of many bosses is to believe your opinion is most important. If you are approaching your employees with this attitude, your ears will be closed and you will be unable to listen or pay attention to them. Letting your mind wander in meetings or sitting back handling memos or e-mails is not listening. One thing at a time. Focus on what your employees are telling you and learn from it. But don't stop there: Listen for ideas from everyone, from the receptionist to the client.

Make a Promise, Keep a Promise

Want to ruin a client's trust or an employee's morale? Simply break your promises. A great boss, says Fox, makes sure everyone keeps their promises. People who keep their promises will flourish, and a great boss not only enables that but makes sure of it.

Seven Common Words

Remember the seven words George Carlin couldn't say on television? Well, Fox's words aren't quite as inflammatory, but in the parlance of the office, they are nearly so. He thinks you should use these: "I don't know. What do you think?" Wow, a boss who doesn't know everything. Radical, isn't it? But it encourages your people to tell you what they think you need to know (and not just what they think you want to hear). You can tell an effective boss by whether this technique really works.

Don't Shoot from the Lip

There's a theme running through the book, that great bosses hold their tongues and their thoughts. Here's another tip: Be careful what you say. Sometimes the first thing coming to mind is not well thought out or properly worded. Your words carry much weight and set the tone for the agency. Fox shares a quote attributed to retired University of Michigan professor Gene Jennings that is worth repeating: "To an employee, a boss' whisper is like a lion's roar."

Never Be Little, Never Belittle

Humiliation has no place, public or private, in business. Never embarrass a staffer, disrespect them or make sarcastic remarks about them. Do not accuse without solid evidence. Great bosses are emotionally tough and can make those tough decisions. But also, you must care enough to be tough and kind, often simultaneously. Bullies, tyrants and their like are weak, not strong. Those types of behaviors are signs of abuse of authority and will gain no respect from employees.

Be Firm, Fair and Friendly, But Not a Friend

Set clear production and service goals, budgets and deadlines, then firmly enforce them. Brook no excuses, but as you're holding people accountable, be sure to reward success. Great bosses, says Fox, are friendly, but not friends. That's the way most employees would prefer it. Along with this, avoid relationships that can appear to result in favoritism.

Spend 90% of Your Time with Your Best People

This might not sound easy to do. After all, the squeaky wheel gets the oil, right? But if you want to enable your best employees to remain at the top of their game, they need and deserve your attention. Put 60% of your effort into supervising, training and coaching your A's and B's. Spend another 30% of your time with high-potential employees. Spend only 10% of your time with your C's and D's. Many superstars, while appearing independent and confident, actually thrive on attention. It makes them perform even better.

Responsibility

Where does the buck stop? With you, obviously. It seems today there are so many "role models" who parse language and skate around the actual statement of "I did it" or "I'm responsible," but in an agency setting, that's a recipe for disaster. A great boss doesn't look for scapegoats or make excuses. Great bosses protect good employees when they make mistakes and never sacrifice someone to save themselves.

Great Expectations

Another way to think about setting great expectations is to challenge your people to do the extraordinary. It's not a matter of simply stretching goals. Rather, it's an attitude. As with all elements of agency culture and philosophy, this starts with the boss and, if successfully transmitted, carries down through all the workers.

Room to Improve

So, now that you've seen the top-line summary of Fox's challenging, common sense book, tell me: Are you a great boss? Probably, you're not. I am not. We all have ways we can improve.

In my case, I continually am amazed at what I learn from reading a book over and over again. I will never be the world's best boss, but that will never stop me from changing and, I hope, getting better.

I challenge you to do the same. The next time you are on a plane, riding the stationary bike, sitting on the beach or finding yourself somewhere with a couple of quiet hours, do yourself and your employees a big favor. Check out the full version of How to Become a Great Boss and spend some time considering how you can unleash the great boss that's inside. Remember, it's not about you.

As the book explains, it provides "the rules for getting and keeping the best employees." Putting your best effort into being a great boss will certainly help you, too, but in the long run, its best effect will be to make your employees much happier and more effective and thus make your firm more successful.